Collaboration: An Essential Element of Systems Leadership.

Collaboration in a system isn’t a moral virtue… it’s an essential element of systems leadership.

Imagine you are growing a garden. If you’re not a gardener (I’m very much aspiring to be), you’ll have to imagine even harder. Your imaginary goal is to make a beautiful blossoming garden.

There are several components to a garden, some in our control, some not.  The flowers, plants and trees we might plant, the soil and compost, the size of the garden and the weather conditions. Starting our thought exercise here each component has been perfectly optimised to meet its objective.

The sun shines and the rain pours in the exact amounts required to feed and nourish every plant.

The soil is full of nutrients and drains perfectly.

The seed of each flower, plant and tree we plant is guaranteed to grow healthily.

… but you still don’t have a garden.  The “beautiful garden” outcome is only possible when the components work together in the right sequence.  The sun shines and the rain pours on the soil where the seeds are planted.  The quality and quantity of the components certainly contribute to making the garden “beautiful” (as anyone who has tried to grow old seeds in old compost will tell you) but alone they are simply weather, a space and, potentially, bird food.  They are not a beautiful garden.

So, what has this got to do with collaboration in systems?

Let’s start with exploring how we are defining a system here. A system is “a set of things… interconnected in such a way that they produce their own pattern of behaviour over time” (Meadows, 2008).  The key here is that the system has its own behaviour separate from but interdependent with the things that comprise it.

A beautiful garden is the sum of its component parts and it is something completely new, created from the interconnectedness of the component parts. It is important to make sure that each part of a garden-system is working well, like seeds being new, but each part of the system being optimised does not create an optimised system.  Components are interconnected and interdependent.  Therefore if the connections are not optimised the system will not be optimised (Deming, 2000). You’ve still got to work to make the garden beautiful.

Deming proposes that a system must be managed for it to work well. In this sense Deming means that if we want to change the outcomes of a system it must be done intentionally and with a system purpose in mind.  This isn’t about someone directing every component in the system. It is about creating the conditions where cooperation can occur so that the efforts of everyone in the system are aimed towards optimising the system. Without collaborative intention and direction, the components of a system can become increasingly independent of each other, which in turn will lead to the failure of the system (Deming, 2000).

You may have heard the phrase, “every system is perfectly designed to achieve the results it achieves,” which is attributed to various people, Deming included.  This initially sounds pessimistic when we consider the reason we want systems to change is that the results are not the ones we want to achieve.  It should rather be considered a point for hope; we have an opportunity to consider the design of the system in a way that we have not perhaps had the opportunity to do so before.

How the components of your garden come together will determine whether it is beautiful or not.

Beyond systems theory, collaboration also resonates with something deeply human. A quick Google search will bring up numerous results to the query, “are human beings social creatures?”  The vast majority resoundingly state that we are built to be social.   It therefore makes intrinsic sense to us that we should collaborate and work in partnership in systems change. It is a good thing to do because it feels like the right thing to do deep within us.

Collaboration in a system is even more than a moral virtue though.  It is not only the good and right thing to do. If a system is a set of interconnected things, then collaboration is an essential element in changing the system.  Lasting system change requires working collectively because no one part of the system, no matter how good it is, can change the outcomes of the system on its own. Outcomes emerge from collaborative interactions in and across the system.

The garden can be the perfect temperature with the perfect rainfall, but if the new seeds remain in the packet you end up with warm and perfectly watered soil… not a beautiful garden.

The role of a system leader is to seek an understanding of the interconnectedness and interdependency of the components in a system and remove conflicts and barriers, so that the components have a better opportunity to work well together.  This again reinforces the essential nature of collaboration; we each hold different perspectives of the system and different influence within the system.  By bringing together these different perspectives and influences we are, collectively, better able to understand the system and the conflicts and barriers, and in turn better equipped to influence removing them.

As gardeners we need to combine the sun, rain, soil and seeds together in a way that means the garden blooms. The combination of each component with the others requires a specific approach at the right time.  We could just throw the seeds out randomly but the likelihood is that they aren’t going to end up in the best conditions to grow and bloom.

Understanding that collaboration matters is only the starting point. Collaboration requires us to understand the system we are working within, connecting people and perspectives that might otherwise remain separate, and continually learn as conditions evolve. Three principles can help guide this work: understanding context, working across layers of the system, and learning our way through complexity.

Understanding context; you’ve got to know where you are to get to where you want to go.  Hard work and best efforts alone will not change the system.  You need knowledge of the system to apply hard work and make best efforts in the right places.  If people do not understand the system they cannot improve it.

People working in a system will not by themselves learn a better way.  This is not to say we’re incapable, but rather if we had the different perspectives we needed to change the system, we’d already be making the changes needed.  We need to get a different perspective on the system in order to understand it better.

Through collaboration we can bring together the different perspectives and understanding of the system that we have, to get a better understanding of the whole.  If the only bit of the garden we know and understand is the soil, there’s no way we can make a beautiful garden.

Working across layers of the system; applying the socio-ecological model. The socio-ecological model encourages us to think of systems as a series of interconnected layers, where changes in one layer influence what is possible in all the others.

To influence and deliver change in a system we need to work across the layers.  Collaboration is essential here because, as a general rule of thumb, our roles, responsibilities and influence are unlikely to extend across every layer.

We may want to influence or make a change in a layer we have no direct link to, so connecting and collaborating with someone working in that layer can help us extend our collective influence.  Further, because the layers of the system are interconnected and interdependent, anything we change in the layers we work in will impact on the layers we don’t work in, whether we intend it or not. By collaborating across layers of the system we can make intentional, informed decisions about the changes we will make, and create the conditions for change to happen.

Continuing to grow our garden analogy here… You follow all the steps perfectly. Everything was optimised according to all the guidance you can get hold of. But the resulting garden isn’t quite as beautiful as you hoped. Perhaps the seeds you chose flowered exactly as intended, but now you see them in the context of the wider garden they don’t look right. One layer of the garden influenced the overall outcomes of the whole garden.

Learning our way through complexity; there are different types of problems.  When working in systems it is helpful to consider there are different types of problems.  There are simple problems which can be clearly defined, clearly described and there is a clear solution which, if we follow the steps exactly, will resolve the problem.

There are complicated problems, which for the sake of brevity here, could be considered as a set of connected simple problems – at their core they can be solved by following the solution blueprint. Like simple problems they are linear with a clear cause and effect between applying the solution and solving the problem.

Finally, we have complex problems; there is no known solution only best efforts, solutions we do apply may not have the outcomes we expected, and the problem is dynamic.  Every time we feel we’re making progress the problem seems to change and shift. Unlike simple and complicated problems they are non-linear and there is no cause and effect between applying the solution and seeing a resolution to the problem.

Systems are in a constant state of evolution and change (whether we want it to be or not) because the world is dynamic.  We therefore should approach systems change as a complex problem, where we are learning about the system with every best effort we make to change it.  Collaboration can help us here because it enables us to create and build connections across the complex system.  This doesn’t reduce the complexity of the system. Knowing more about the system does not make it less dynamic.  Instead it helps us to challenge assumptions and learn from others, meaning we can work with the system’s dynamism instead of against it.

In our beautiful garden example, we have the weather to contend with.  We have no direct control over the weather, only indirect influence by looking at the weather forecast and understanding our local climate. Even with weather forecasting it is short term and there is no guarantee from one year to the next that each season will look and feel the same.  The garden-system is dynamic; if we always apply the same solutions to making it beautiful there’s no guarantee it will work.

This means there is no endpoint on collaboration… you’re not “done.”  There is always more to develop, to learn about and understand, to implement… the purpose and aim of the collaboration may evolve over time, precisely because the system is in a constant state of evolution and change.

To create a beautiful garden we have to constantly tend it and adjust what we’re doing to keep it on the track to “beautiful.”

Improving the outcomes of a system requires a focus on how the elements of a system work together to optimise the system.  To do this we need to be able to share, openly, transparently and without judgement, how things are working together.  Being able to do this is often hampered by a fundamental challenge in systems change; what is best for the individual parts may not be what is best for the system.

More directly; when each part of a system is given its own outcomes to achieve and is optimised for that outcome, without consideration of how these affect the desired goal of the system, rational behaviour can become detrimental to the system. This is the heart of competition in a system.  Whether by design or not, competition limits the outcomes a system can achieve through collaboration.

I’ve seen this happen in real time, where it’s acknowledged that shifting an activity from one part of the system to another would benefit users of the system. But doing so would mean one part of the system would miss their targets, therefore they could not support the change in the system.

Going back to our garden; the aim is to create a beautiful garden and to do this we need the whole garden to thrive. If we were to focus our attention on everything in the garden growing as big as possible with the most flowers possible it would quickly become overgrown or perhaps some plants would be crowded out of the garden. The overall beauty of the garden is diminished because each plant is “winning.”

Instead we’d want to be considered about how we plant the garden, with different plants playing different roles. Some will shade those that need shade in hot weather. Some may keep the soil healthy. Others yet attract pollinators to keep the cycle of the garden going.

Collaboration is often talked about as a “good thing.” It’s something many of us value instinctively, and most organisations would point to it as an important way of working. Systems thinking suggests it is more than that. If the outcomes of a system emerge through the interaction of interconnected and interdependent parts, then collaboration isn’t simply helpful, it’s fundamental to how change happens.

As we’ve considered collaboration in systems, we’ve considered growing a beautiful garden. A garden doesn’t become beautiful because one plant grows taller than all the others. Equally, it doesn’t thrive because the gardener focuses all of their attention on a single flower bed whilst ignoring everything around it. The health of the garden emerges from the countless interactions between plants, insects, soil, water, weather and the gardener. Each plays a role, and each influences the others.

The same is true in the systems we lead. Improving outcomes requires us to look beyond individual teams, organisations or interventions and pay greater attention to the relationships between them. It requires us to understand the wider context, work across organisational and professional boundaries, and learn continuously as conditions change.

In this sense, collaboration is not a separate activity that sits alongside systems leadership. It is one of the primary ways that systems leadership is put into practice. By strengthening the connections between people, perspectives and parts of a system, we create the conditions for the system as a whole to flourish. And, like any good gardener, that is often where our attention is needed most.

Pete Smith